事实、价值缠结中的刑法因果关系解析——以希拉里·普特南事实与价值缠结理论为分析视角

    The Analysis of the Causation of Criminal Law in the fact-value Entangling Relationship-To analyze the fact-and-value entanglement theory of Hilary Putnam

    • 摘要: 自休谟始,事实与价值截然分离,一定意义上支持了长期处于通说地位的“刑法因果关系是客观事实”的论断。希拉里·普特南以“事实价值”为基础提出缠结理论,终结了事实与价值二分法的论断。刑法因果关系判断同样契合事实要素与价值要素缠结的现实。在内容上,刑法事实因果关系是扩展和延长因果事实要素的界定和分析;刑法价值因果关系是主体价值、客体价值及相互转化、限定。在本质上,刑法事实因果关系是行为支配关系、相关关系;刑法价值因果关系是刑法法律关系,一种是而又不限于结果导向主义的产物。刑法事实因果关系负担着确证案件事实、奠基法律因果关系的功能,而刑法价值因果关系具有拟制、确立两种功能。刑法因果关系是一种以事实价值为基础,基于发现的价值选择,通过发现、解构与重构,解释两条路径构建。

       

      Abstract: Since Hume's "A Treatise of Human Nature" was published,the state of the complete separation of fact from value,in a sense,offers the support to the thesis of the causation of criminal law as objective facts,which had been in a position of common remarks for a rather long period. The entanglement theory,put forward by Hilary Putnam with the basis of fact-value theory,puts an end to the thesis of the Fact and Value Dichotomy. The causal judgment rules in criminal law also conform to the reality of the entanglement of facts and values. In content,the fact-value relationship of the facts in criminal law extends the definition and analysis of the elements of the causal facts-the causation of the value of criminal law is mutual transformation and definition between the subjective value and objective value. In essence,the causation of the facts in criminal law is the one of behavior controlling and interrelation. That is,the causation of the facts in criminal law is legal relation in criminal law,which is one of the products but doesn't just originate from result-oriented pragmatism. The causation of the facts in criminal law has the function of confirming the facts in cases and laying the foundation to causality in law and the causality of the value in criminal law performs two functions of drafting and confirmation. The causation of the value in criminal law is choice of value by researching based on the fact-value theory,which is constructed by the two ways-one is of discovering and deconstruction and the other of reconstruction and explanation.

       

    /

    返回文章
    返回
    Baidu
    map