公私领域划分下的网络暴力刑法治理

    Criminal Law Governance of Cyber Violence under the Division of Public and Private Spheres

    • 摘要: 对于侵犯私人领域的网络暴力,刑法的限制较少。在网络社会,个体不仅无力抵抗公权力主体的侵害,而且无力抵抗私权力主体的侵害。为了确保公权力始终在法律的边界内行使,应当区分刑法介入公共领域和私人领域的程度。刑法应当积极介入严重危害社会秩序的私人领域的网络暴力,并且适用公诉程序。对涉及公众人物公共性的网络暴力,应当谨慎适用刑法;对涉及公众人物私人性的网络暴力,有必要强化刑法的保护。“受害者脆弱论”和“受害者不完美论”都是对于网络暴力关注的失焦。网络诽谤“情节严重”的认定过程应是综合考量各方面因素的实质判断过程,其中,精神损害是判断因素之一。

       

      Abstract: The criminal law is less restrictive with regard to cyber violence that violates the private sphere. In the cyber society, individuals are powerless to resist aggression not only by subjects of public power, but also by subjects of private power. In order to ensure that public power is always exercised within the boundaries of the law, a distinction should be made between the extent to which criminal law intervenes in the public sphere and the private sphere. Criminal law should actively intervene in cyberviolence in the private sphere, which seriously jeopardizes social order, and apply the public prosecution procedure. Criminal law should be applied with caution to cyberviolence involving the public nature of public figures, while for cyberviolence involving the private nature of public figures, it is necessary to strengthen the protection of criminal law. The “victim vulnerability theory” and the “victim imperfection theory” are both out of focus with regard to cyberviolence. The process of determining the “aggravating circumstances” of online defamation should be a substantive judgment process that takes into account all factors, of which moral damage is one.

       

    /

    返回文章
    返回
    Baidu
    map