出资责任新样态的适用困境及其破解评未届期出资股权转让后的补充责任

    Application Dilemma of and Solution to the New Capital Contribution Liability PatternComment on Supplementary Liability after Transfer of Non-expired Capital Contribution Equity

    • 摘要: 《公司法修订草案》(二、三审稿)首次规定未届期出资股权转让后,转让人对受让人未按期缴纳的出资承担补充责任。该补充责任是中国出资责任领域立法与相关司法实践中的新责任样态。适用该补充责任会面临股权转让缔约成本、转让人监督成本以及权利人权利实现成本升高的困境。破解该困境的可能路径:以其他责任模式替代补充责任模式;改进既有补充责任。由于股东出资义务既是契约法上的义务,也是组织法上的义务,困境破解路径的选择需兼顾组织法与契约法的相关法律规则与原则。考虑到对公司资本充足与股权转让自由的均衡保护、公司法出资责任体系的内在和谐性,以及公司内部激励效用的充分发挥,替代路径并不可行,应采改进路径。具体改进措施包括允许转让人与受让人之间进行内部追偿、限制转让人的责任范围,以及减少权利实现的程序负担等。

       

      Abstract: The Revised Draft of the Company Law (second and third drafts) stipulates that after the transfer of non-expired capital contribution equity, the transferor shall bear supplementary liability, if transferee fails to pay on time. This supplementary liability is a new form of capital contribution liability in the legislation and judicial practice of company law in China. The application of this supplementary liability will increase the contracting cost of equity transfer, the supervision cost of the transferor and the cost of realizing rights. The possible ways to solve this dilemma include: to replace the supplementary liability model with other liability models, and to improv the existing supplementary liability. As the shareholder’s contribution obligation is not only an obligation in contract law, but also an obligation in organization law, it is necessary to take into account the relevant legal rules and principles of organization law and contract law. Considering the balanced protection between the company’s capital adequacy and the freedom of equity transfer, the internal harmony of the company law’s capital liability system, and the effect of the company’s internal incentive rules.The replacement path is not feasible, and an improvement path should be adopted. The specific improvement measures include allowing internal contract between the transferor and the transferee, limiting the transferor’s liability and reducing the procedural burden of rights realization.

       

    /

    返回文章
    返回
    Baidu
    map